Orthodoxy tsis yog Christianity. Ntu 2
Orthodoxy tsis yog Christianity. Ntu 2

Video: Orthodoxy tsis yog Christianity. Ntu 2

Video: Orthodoxy tsis yog Christianity. Ntu 2
Video: Lub Zog Nruab Nrog (Hmong Dubbed) 2024, Tej zaum
Anonim

Yog li dab tsi yog Orthodoxy?

Qhov tseeb, tiag tiag Orthodoxy tsis yog ib tug ntseeg kev ntseeg, raws li ROC tab tom sim ntxias peb niaj hnub no, tab sis yog ib qho kev ntseeg pagan ntawm cov neeg pe hawm hnub. Vim li cas hnub pe hawm? Zoo, tom qab tag nrho, peb muaj lub cim ntawm Lub Hnub nyob ib puag ncig thiab txhua qhov chaw! Nco ntsoov tus ntoo khaub lig hla kev nkag mus rau lub thaj ntawm St. Isaac's Cathedral. Muaj lub hnub nyob hauv nruab nrab. Thiab qhov no yog mosaic nyob rau hauv nruab nrab ntawm lub tsev, kuv ib leeg pom lub cim ntawm lub hnub muaj, los yog dab tsi? Txwv tsis pub, cov neeg txawj ntse yuav rov qab los dua thiab pib qw tias kuv yog kev dag ntxias thiab nws yog lub sijhawm rau kuv mus ntsib kws kho mob hlwb.

21 Isakiy Center
21 Isakiy Center

Thiab qhov no yog qhov pom ntawm lub tsev teev ntuj palace hauv Peterhof. Ntawm txhua qhov hla muaj lub Hnub.

22 Peterhof Palace Lub Koom Txoos 01
22 Peterhof Palace Lub Koom Txoos 01
23 Peterhof Palace Lub Koom Txoos 02
23 Peterhof Palace Lub Koom Txoos 02

Thiab muaj ntau ntau cov piv txwv zoo sib xws, thaum lub hnub ci cim tau siv rau hauv kev tsim ntawm Orthodox pawg ntseeg. Nyob rau ntau lub tuam tsev, lub hnub yog piav nyob rau hauv nruab nrab ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig. Nov yog lwm lub tsev teev ntuj ntawm Catherine Palace hauv Tsarskoye Selo.

24 CC - Palace Church 01
24 CC - Palace Church 01
25 TsS - Catherine Palace hla lub tsev teev ntuj
25 TsS - Catherine Palace hla lub tsev teev ntuj

Thiab kuv twb tau hais txog qhov piv txwv zoo tshaj plaws thaum kuv tham txog Yaroslavl, tab sis kuv yuav rov hais dua.

26 Yaroslavl 08
26 Yaroslavl 08

Qhov no yog ib tug belfry nrog lub tsev teev ntuj ntawm lub Pechersk icon ntawm leej niam ntawm Vajtswv, nyob rau hauv lub ntsiab dome peb pom ib tug Greek, uas yog, ib tug Byzantine ntoo khaub lig nrog sib npaug kawg, thiab nyob rau lwm yam domes muaj tsuas yog cov cim ntawm lub hnub nyob rau hauv lawv. daim ntawv ntshiab, tsis txawm hla!

Kuv puas yog tib tug uas pom tau? Puas muaj leej twg pom qhov no lossis kuv puas muaj "glitches"?

Qhov tseeb tias tag nrho cov cim no tseem tsis tau muaj sijhawm los hloov dua ib zaug qhia tias kev hloov pauv tau tshwm sim tsis ntev los no, nyob rau nruab nrab ntawm lub xyoo pua 19th, tsis yog ua ntej.

Cov tswm ciab uas cov ntseeg Orthodox teeb hauv lawv lub Tuam Tsev ua cim dab tsi? Nws symbolizes Divine Light! Qhov no yog ib qho piv txwv ntawm lub hnub me me, uas Orthodox teeb thaum hmo ntuj txhawm rau tuav lawv txoj kev sib txuas nrog Vajtswv Leej Txiv Saum Ntuj Ceeb Tsheej. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, tswm ciab tau tsim tshwj xeeb los ntawm beeswax, uas muv tau txais los ntawm nectar thiab pollen ntawm paj, uas yog tag nrho cov tib lub zog ntawm lub hnub, ntes thiab hloov los ntawm paj thiab muv. Qhov tsaus ntuj ntawm hmo ntuj enveloped lub ntiaj teb? Peb taws tswm ciab, thiab Vajtswv Leej Txiv tseem muab Vajtswv lub teeb rau peb los ntawm qhov hluav taws kub tswm ciab. Plua plav thiab pa taws ntim lub ntiaj teb tom qab muaj kev puas tsuaj ntawm lub ntiaj teb, zais lub hnub ntawm peb? Peb rov teeb lub tswm ciab kom Vaj Ntsuj Plig Dawb Huv illuminates txhua yam nyob ib ncig ntawm peb, thiab peb muaj peev xwm xav tias Vajtswv Leej Txiv tsis tau tso peb tseg.

Vim li cas tus thawj Orthodoxy tsuas yog kev ntseeg pagan? Rau qhov no nws yog ib qho tsim nyog kom nkag siab tias lo lus "pagan cult" nws tus kheej txhais li cas. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, tsis tas yuav xa kuv mus rau cov ntawv qub ntawm Phau Tshiab, raug liam tias yog lus Greek thaum ub. Paganism, pagan, qhov no yog raws nraim peb, Lavxias teb sab lus, thiab tsis yog lub Greek qub. Vim li cas raws nraim nws tau siv hauv kev txhais lus yog lwm lo lus nug.

Yog tias koj saib cov lus txhais lus ntawm lub ntsiab lus ntawm lo lus "paganism", ces yuav luag txhua qhov chaw nws yuav sau ib yam dab tsi zoo li:.

Ntawd yog, txawm tias raws li qhov kev txhais tsis tseeb no, peb pom tias Orthodoxy uas peb pom ntawm Romanovs thaum ntxov, txiav txim siab los ntawm txoj kev ntawm lawv lub neej thiab kev tsim cov palaces, yog qhov tseeb ntawm polytheism uas peb niaj hnub no tau nthuav tawm ua "Greek myths xwb. ", artificially hloov lawv mus rau hauv qhov tob centuries. Thiab nyob rau hauv ib qho ntawm cov hauj lwm ntawm Nosovsky thiab Fomenko nyob rau hauv New Chronology, nws yog hais tias nyob rau hauv ib tug ntawm cov qub Tuam Tsev ntawm Suzdal, nyob rau hauv lub ancient painting ntawm lub dome, Yexus Chrysos yog depicted surrounded los ntawm 12 Thwj Tim, tab sis cov Thwj Tim yog depicted. nrog cov cim ntawm ancient Greek pagan Gods.

Tab sis qhov kev piav qhia ntawm lub ntsiab lus ntawm lo lus "paganism" yog cuav, vim hais tias tib yam yog txhais los ntawm cov uas twb muaj lawm lo lus "idolatry". Thiab qhov twg peb ntsib lub npe hu ua "synonyms", feem ntau muaj kev hloov ntawm lub ntsiab lus. Vim li cas thiaj tsim ob lo lus sib txawv kom txhais tau tib yam?

Nws yooj yim pom tias ob lo lus "pagan" thiab lo lus "pagan" yog nyob ntawm lub hauv paus "lus". Lwm tus sau zoo ntawm Lavxias teb sab lus dab neeg, Alexander Nikolaevich Afanasyev, nrhiav pom tias muaj ib tug thiaj li hu ua "qhov ncauj kev lig kev cai" nyob rau hauv Russia. Tib neeg tau qhia tib zaj dab neeg lossis epics rau nws nyob rau ntau qhov chaw, rov hais dua cov ntawv nyeem rau lo lus. Qhov sib txawv, yog tias muaj, yog qhov tsis tseem ceeb heev. Thaum nws pib paub tias yog vim li cas qhov no yog li ntawd, nws tau pom tias cov yawg koob tau yuam cov menyuam yaus kom nco qab thiab rov hais dua cov lus tales thiab epics txawm tias thaum yau. Qhov no yog dab tsi "paganism" yog - hloov kev paub los ntawm cov lus, los ntawm kev hais lus nyob.

Muaj ob txoj hauv kev los xa kev paub ntawm sab ntsuj plig. Qhov thib ib yog los ntawm tus Ntsuj Plig nyob mus rau lwm tus Ntsuj Plig nyob, uas yog, los ntawm qhov ncauj mus rau qhov ncauj. Qhov no yuav yog tam sim no Paganism … Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, qhov muaj paganism tsis txhais hais tias tsis lees txais kev sau ntawv thiab cov phau ntawv, tab sis lawv tau siv los ua qhov tseeb ntawm kev xa cov ntaub ntawv, cov ntaub ntawv, thiab tsis yog kev paub ntawm sab ntsuj plig. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, yog tias koj muaj cov thev naus laus zis ntawm Paganism, tom qab ntawd hauv qhov xwm txheej tseem ceeb koj yuav tuaj yeem nthuav tawm txoj hauv kev no txawm tias cov ntaub ntawv uas tau sau tseg hauv phau ntawv, uas tau ua los ntawm peb cov poj koob yawm txwv.

Lwm txoj hauv kev, uas tau qhia los ntawm Yehauvas, yog kev hloov pauv ntawm kev paub ntawm sab ntsuj plig los ntawm "cov ntawv dawb huv", uas yog, los ntawm vaj lug kub, ib phau ntawv. Tsis muaj kev sib cuag ncaj qha ntawm tus Ntsuj Plig ntawm tus kws qhia ntawv thiab tus ntsuj plig ntawm tus tub kawm. Qhov tseeb, tsuas yog cov ntaub ntawv raug xa mus, thiab tsis yog tus cwj pwm ntawm nws tus kws sau ntawv rau cov ntaub ntawv no, uas yog qhov tseem ceeb heev rau kev nkag siab qhov tseeb, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog kev paub ntawm sab ntsuj plig, kev paub txog dab tsi "zoo" thiab dab tsi "tsis zoo". Los ntawm ib phau ntawv, los ntawm cov ntaub ntawv sau rau ntawm daim ntawv, nws yooj yim dua kom tsis meej pem thiab dag ib tug neeg dua li los ntawm kev sib txuas lus ncaj qha. Rau qhov no, phau ntawv kev lig kev cai tau tsim, yog li nrog nws cov kev pab nws yuav yooj yim rau kev dag thiab dag neeg. Koj pom, nws tau sau rau hauv phau ntawv! Yog, tsis yog nyob rau hauv ib phau ntawv yooj yim, tab sis nyob rau hauv ib tug "dawb huv" !!! Tus Tswv nws tus kheej dictated nws rau tus yaj saub rau xws li thiab xws li, koj yuav ua li cas tsis ntseeg nws?! Thiab tib lub sijhawm peb tsis tuaj yeem paub tias tus neeg sau phau ntawv no xav li cas tiag. Nws yog qhov nyuaj heev los nkaum koj qhov kev xav tiag tiag hauv kev sib txuas lus ncaj qha, ntau, tsawg heev tuaj yeem ua tau. Tab sis thaum sau ntawv, qhov no yooj yim dua ua, nrog rau los ntawm kev qhia qhov tsim nyog distortions rau lwm tus neeg cov ntawv, uas ib tug neeg sau siab dawb paug, yog li hais lus, los ntawm Ntsuj Plig. Tsis muaj leej twg yuav muaj peev xwm rov hais dua cov lus qhuab qhia ntawm Yexus kom nws yuav muaj txiaj ntsig zoo rau tib neeg, tab sis txhawm rau kho nws phau ntawv keeb kwm lossis muab tso rau hauv nws lub qhov ncauj hauv cov ntawv uas nws tsis tau hais yog ib txoj haujlwm daws tau tag nrho.

Qhov kev tawm tsam ntawm pagan lossis qhov ncauj kev lig kev cai thiab phau ntawv kab lig kev cai tau mus rau qee lub sijhawm. Nco txog Phau Tshiab. Rau txhua qhov tseeb uas tau hais nyob rau ntawd, Yexus yog tus sawv cev ntawm cov neeg pagan, uas yog, qhov ncauj kab ke! Nws tus kheej tsis tau sau ib nqe vaj lug kub. Nws hla kev paub li cas? Nws sau neeg thiab nyeem cov lus qhuab qhia rau lawv. Nws tham nrog tib neeg lossis teb cov lus nug nrog cov lus piv txwv, yuam kom lawv tig rau lawv lub hlwb thiab xav txog kev xav kom thiaj li nrhiav tau cov lus teb raug lawv tus kheej. Tsis tas li ntawd xwb, Yexus puas tau hais kom nws cov thwjtim sau “Tswv Yexus Phau Tshiab”? Tsis yog! Nws hais rau lawv tias: “Cia li mus qhia lwm haiv neeg.” Txawm hais tias raws li cov lus dab neeg hais, cov phau ntawv Phau Tshiab tau sau los ntawm Yexus cov thwj tim ntau dua li cov xwm txheej lawv tus kheej. Thiab feem ntau ntawm cov tshooj ntxiv ntawm "Tsab Ntawv Tshiab" feem ntau yog tsim los ntawm cov ntawv ntawm Povlauj, uas yog tus hu ua "13 tus tubtxib" thiab tus uas tsis yog Yexus ib tug thwjtim, tsis tau pom nws, thiab tsis raug tsa. los ntawm nws (ib qho ntawm lub cim nco txog ntawm lub Koom Txoos Orthodox, uas muab txoj cai los ua pov thawj, tshaj tawm thiab ua rituals).

Yexus tsav leej twg tawm ntawm Tuam Tsev? Cov neeg muag phau ntawv. Yexus tsis tu ncua nrog leej twg, thiab leej twg ua siab phem nws tsis tu ncua? Cov kws sau ntawv thiab cov Falixais, uas yog, cov neeg sawv cev ntawm lwm tus, phau ntawv kev lig kev cai. Thiab qhov tseeb yog vim Yexus ua txhaum lawv txoj cai, nws yog cov kws sau ntawv thiab cov Falixais uas thaum kawg tau tsa Yexus tua.

Yog li ntawd, cov ntseeg Vajtswv, koj txoj moo zoo ua pov thawj tias Yexus Khetos yog ib tug neeg dawb huv, uas yog tus coj ntawm qhov ncauj kev coj noj coj ua ntawm kev xa xov ntawm sab ntsuj plig. Thiab nws yog koj cov “cov pov thawj”, uas yog, cov kws sau ntawv thiab cov Falixais uas tau saib xyuas thiab saib xyuas “cov ntawv dawb huv” uas tau muab rau lawv saum toj saud los ntawm lawv tus Tswv Yawmsaub los ntawm “cov yaj saub” tsim los ntawm nws, uas tau muab Yexus ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig. Thiab tom qab ntawd, rau kev tsim kho ntawm lwm tus, lawv tau muab nws lub cev tuag rau saum tus ntoo khaub lig, uas lawv tau dai rau hauv txhua lub koom txoos kom sawv daws pom thiab nco ntsoov tias koj ua dab tsi nrog Vajtswv tiag cov me nyuam, uas tau twv tawm tsam koj tus Tswv.

Rites, postures, kab lus yog pleev xim rau, Leej twg yuav tsum sawv qhov twg, yuav hais li cas.

Yog tias koj ntseeg, tsis txhob nug cov lus nug hauv vain, Txwv tsis pub, lawv tuaj yeem ntsia tau rau ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig.

Yexus yeej nws cov lus nug thiab

Kuv xav tau cov lus teb los ntawm cov kws sau ntawv, Kuv sim piav qhia rau tib neeg tias tsis muaj Vajtswv nyob rau hauv phau ntawv, Thiab raws li kev rau txim rau qhov no, nws dai saum tus ntoo khaub lig.

Thiab tom qab ntawd, rau kev tsim kho ntawm cov xeeb leej xeeb ntxwv, Yog li ntawd koj tsis txhob tsa koj txhais tes tawm tsam cov pov thawj, Nyob rau hauv tag nrho cov pawg ntseeg nyob rau hauv lub feem ntau conspicuous qhov chaw

Lawv pib muab lub cev tuag rau saum ntoo Khaublig.

Thiab tom qab ntawd peb thov Vajtswv hauv qab tus ntoo khaub lig mus rau qhov chaw ntawm ecstasy, Thiab peb mus rau lub tsev teev ntuj nyob rau hauv ib tug phooj ywg neeg coob coob, Thiab tsis muaj leej twg xav tau, Tias Yexus tuag ua ntej peb saum tus ntoo khaub lig! Tsis ciaj sia!

Nov yog lwm daim duab uas kuv coj hauv Yaroslavl Tsev khaws puav pheej.

27 Yaroslavl hla
27 Yaroslavl hla

Tag nrho cov ntoo khaub lig no tau pom thaum khawb hauv Yaroslavl. Nyob rau tib lub sij hawm, lub showcase thov hais tias lawv yog tag nrho cov "Orthodox Christian pectoral crosses." Tab sis qhov no yog ib tug forgery, vim tsuas yog ib tug ntoo khaub lig yog ib tug Christian ntoo khaub lig, qhov loj tshaj plaws nyob rau hauv lub center, ib tug remake ntawm lig 19th caug xyoo, tsuas yog ib tug depicting ib tug crucifixion. Ntawm tag nrho cov lwm yam, tsis muaj ib tug hint ntawm ib tug crucified lub cev. Lub amulet hauv qab no, nrog rau qhov kawg tawg, tsis yog kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig, tab sis ib daim duab ntawm ib tug neeg dawb huv, txij li lub cloak-cape, uas cov txwj laus dawb huv feem ntau yog piav qhia, nyeem tau zoo. Ntxiv mus, qee qhov ntawm cov ntoo khaub lig yog feem ntau tshwj xeeb "Greek" equilateral. Ntawm qee qhov, yog tias koj saib ze, koj tuaj yeem pom yim-taw tes Orthodox ntoo khaub lig sau rau saum.

Yog li ntawd, supposedly Orthodox ntoo khaub lig nrog ib tug crucifix yog ib tug fake, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog pom loj thiab muab tso rau hauv nruab nrab ntawm lub showcase kom nws yuav tsom ntsoov rau thiab tsis muaj ib tug tsis ntseeg dab tsi ntawm crosses tau sau ntawm no. Qhov tseeb, nyob rau hauv Orthodoxy tiag tiag, lawv yeej tsis tau piav txog lub cev raug ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig yim-taw! Ntxiv mus, raws li peb twb pom nyob rau hauv St. Isaac lub Cathedral, lawv feem ntau sim depict nws tsawg li sai tau. Tab sis peb tuaj yeem soj ntsuam tib yam tsis yog nyob ntawd xwb, tab sis kuj tseem nyob hauv Cathedral ntawm Khetos tus Cawm Seej, uas nyuam qhuav rov tsim dua hauv Moscow. Ntxiv mus, nws tau recreated heev ze rau qhov qub, txij li cov duab zoo li no tau muaj sia nyob.

Qhov no yog qhov pom ntawm lub Cathedral ntawm Tswv Yexus tus Cawm Seej, daim duab no tau tshwm sim hauv xyoo 1920.

28 Mosvka 1920s Cathedral of Christ the Savior original 03
28 Mosvka 1920s Cathedral of Christ the Savior original 03

Classic Byzantine Orthodox lub tsev teev ntuj ntawm pagan hnub pe hawm.

Thiab cov no yog cov duab xim coj los rau xyoo 1931 txawm tias ua ntej lub tuam tsev tau tawg, sab nrauv.

29 Moscow
29 Moscow

Thiab qhov pom sab hauv ntawm … Kuv tsis paub txawm tias yuav hu nws li cas, tab sis qhov no yog qhov tseeb tsis yog iconostasis nrog lub thaj tom qab nws, txawm hais tias qhov no yog qhov pom zoo.

30 Moscow
30 Moscow

Yuav kom ncaj ncees, nws zoo nkaus li zoo li lub ntxa los yog mausoleum. Ib chav tshwj xeeb cais hauv qab lub dome nrog tus ntoo khaub lig. Ntxiv mus, muaj yim me me domes nrog crosses nyob rau hauv ib lub voj voog. Qhov no yog dab tsi tab sis lub thaj nrog lub iconostasis. Thiab yog hais tias qhov no yog ib tug neeg faus neeg, hais tias nws yuav tsum yog xws li ib tug tseem ceeb thiab tseem ceeb tus neeg uas kuv txawm ntshai los twv seb nws yuav yog leej twg, yog hais tias xws li ib tug lub tuam tsev tau tsim rau nws … Ntawm tag nrho cov keeb kwm personalities, tsuas yog Feem ntau. Holy Theotokos tuaj yeem tau txais txiaj ntsig zoo li no, Virgin Mary, niam ntawm Yexus. Rau txhua tus neeg, suav nrog cov vaj ntxwv thiab vaj ntxwv, ib lub tuam tsev cais nrog lub qhov ntxa zoo sib xws yog txias dhau, yog li hais, tawm ntawm kev txiav txim. Tab sis cov no tsuas yog cov kev xav uas yog los ntawm kev xav tias qhov qauv no tsim. Kuv tsis muaj qhov tseeb.

Thiab qhov no kuj piav qhia vim li cas cov Bolsheviks yuav tsum rhuav tshem lub Tuam Tsev no.

Tam sim no sab hauv zoo li yuav luag zoo ib yam, tab sis tsuas yog sab nraud, txij li tag nrho cov sab hauv, raws li kuv nkag siab nws, tau raug rhuav tshem.

31 Moscow
31 Moscow

Tab sis dab tsi tseem ceeb rau peb tam sim no, peb rov tsis pom kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig nyob qhov twg! Tsis yog nyob rau ntawm lub Orthodox yim-taw ntoo khaub lig, los yog nyob rau hauv lub Catholic plaub-taw tes. Kuv tsis paub yog tias muaj ib qho duab ntawm kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig, tab sis ib yam dab tsi qhia kuv tias yog muaj, nws kuj yog qhov chaw tawm ntawm sab, zoo li hauv St. Isaac's Cathedral. Ntawd yog, qhov tseeb kev raug ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig nyob rau hauv lub tsev teev ntuj Orthodox tiag tiag yog portrayed raws li ib yam ntawm cov xwm txheej zoo tib yam nyob rau hauv lub neej ntawm Tswv Yexus, uas tsis yog hais txog. Tsis yog txhua yam zoo li hauv pawg ntseeg Catholic, qhov twg cov duab ntawm lub crucifix yeej ib txwm nyob hauv nruab nrab lossis ntawm qhov tawm, tab sis yog li ntawd nws yuav tsum ntes cov parishioners lub qhov muag, kom lawv pheej pom Yexus lub cev tuag saum ntoo khaub lig..

32 Catholic Tuam Tsev, sab hauv 01a
32 Catholic Tuam Tsev, sab hauv 01a
33 Catholic Tuam Tsev, sab hauv 02
33 Catholic Tuam Tsev, sab hauv 02
34 Catholic Tuam Tsev, sab hauv 03
34 Catholic Tuam Tsev, sab hauv 03

Thiab nws tsis muaj teeb meem dab tsi lawv qhia rau koj, vim hais tias cov duab pom yog txoj kev xa xov zoo tshaj plaws, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog tias koj pom nws thaum kawg, thaum koj tawm hauv lub tuam tsev. Qhov no yog ib qho ntawm qhov sib txawv ntawm cov qub Orthodox pawg ntseeg thiab cov Catholic; nyob rau hauv tiag tiag Orthodox pawg ntseeg, lub crucifix yeej tsis sticks tawm.

Tab sis txawm tias Catholic daim duab ntawm kev ntsia saum ntoo Khaublig yog cuav, txij li qhov tseeb tus ntoo khaub lig tsis muaj dab tsi cuam tshuam nrog kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig. Tsis muaj leej twg tau ua ib qho kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig vim nws yog txoj haujlwm tsis tsim nyog. Lub crucifixion yeej ib txwm ua nyob rau hauv cov duab ntawm tsab ntawv T, thaum ib tug transverse keeb, ib tug bar los yog ib tug txiav ntawm ib tug cav tau txuas mus rau tus ncej nyob rau hauv ib txoj kev los yog lwm yam nyob rau saum toj. Nws yog qhov yooj yim heev kom ntseeg tau tias qhov no yog qhov tseeb, txij li cov neeg ua yeeb yam nyob sab Europe medieval nyob rau hauv feem ntau paintings depict lub crucifix precisely nyob rau hauv daim ntawv ntawm tsab ntawv T.

35 Р01 Anton Wienzam crucifixion 1540
35 Р01 Anton Wienzam crucifixion 1540
36 P02 Durer Crucifixion 01
36 P02 Durer Crucifixion 01
37 P03 Durer Lub Xya Hli Ntuj Kev Tu Siab ntawm Niam Mab Liab raug ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig
37 P03 Durer Lub Xya Hli Ntuj Kev Tu Siab ntawm Niam Mab Liab raug ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig
38 P04 Lucas Cranach Crucifixion 1515
38 P04 Lucas Cranach Crucifixion 1515
39 Р05 Lucas Cranach Crucifixion nrog centurion 1536
39 Р05 Lucas Cranach Crucifixion nrog centurion 1536
40 P06 Jörg Bray Exaltation ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig 1524
40 P06 Jörg Bray Exaltation ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig 1524

Yog li ntawd, tus Catholic plaub-taw tes ntoo khaub lig tsis muaj dab tsi cuam tshuam nrog kev raug ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig. Medieval Western European cov kws ua yeeb yam paub zoo txog yuav ua li cas piav txog kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig, txij li thaum lawv lub sij hawm xws li kev txi tau siv dav heev. Nyob rau hauv ib co paintings, txawm li cas los, muaj ib tug ntsiav tshuaj daig nyob rau hauv los ntawm saum toj no, uas lawv sim kom dhau los ntawm lub sab sauv kawg ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig, los yog raws li lub sab sauv lub ntsiab ntawm lub yim-taw tes Orthodox ntoo khaub lig, txij li thaum lub ntsiav tshuaj no tau hais nyob rau hauv lub Txoj moo zoo. Tab sis qhov no yog ib ntsiav tshuaj uas muaj cov ntawv sau, thiab tsis yog lub ntsiab lus ntawm kev ntsia saum ntoo khaub lig nws tus kheej.

Lub cim ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig yog heev ancient, nws muaj nyob rau hauv ntau haiv neeg ntawm ntau haiv neeg thiab tsis muaj dab tsi ua rau lub crucifixion. Thaum cov neeg Yudais tsim lub Koom Txoos Catholic, lawv txiav lub cim ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig, hloov nws nrog ib tug crucifix. Thiab thaum nyob rau hauv nruab nrab ntawm lub xyoo pua 19th, ua raws li lub zwm txwv muaj koob muaj npe, lub tsev teev ntuj Orthodox raug ntes, lub cev tuag ntawm Tswv Yexus kuj tau muab tso rau ntawm lub Orthodox yim-taw ntoo khaub lig. Yog li ntawd, tam sim no nyob rau hauv ntau lub tsev teev ntuj, tshwj xeeb tshaj yog cov tshiab, nyob rau hauv lub center hangs ib tug zoo xws li cov cuav crucifix nrog ib tug yim-taw tes Orthodox ntoo khaub lig. Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, lawv tau dhau los ua siab tawv heev uas nyob rau qee qhov chaw lawv kuj muab pob txha taub hau nrog cov pob txha, lub cim ntawm tib neeg kev txi, hauv qab no.

Nws yog qhov tseeb vim yog kev qaug dab peg thiab kev hloov ntawm txoj kev ntseeg uas hu ua "split" tshwm sim, uas niaj hnub no lawv tau nthuav tawm rau peb tias "kev hloov pauv ntawm Patriarch Nikon", tau tsiv 200 xyoo dhau los. Nyob rau hauv cov xwm txheej ntawm 17th thiab 19th centuries, muaj ntau yam zoo sib xws, uas nyob rau hauv qhov chaw coincide mus txog rau ib xyoo. Teeb meem nyob rau hauv Russia thaum pib ntawm lub xyoo pua 17th, uas yog vim li cas, los ntawm txoj kev, ntau cov kws tshawb fawb hu ua lub ntuj cataclysm, uas coj mus rau ib tug txias snap thiab ob peb xyoo lean. Cov xwm txheej zoo sib xws, suav nrog kev hloov pauv huab cua, tau tshwm sim thaum pib ntawm lub xyoo pua 19th, thaum lub sijhawm Romanovs thaum kawg txeeb Moscow. Kev ntes ntawm Moscow los ntawm Romanovs, nrog kev txhawb nqa ntawm Fabkis, yog hnub no tau nthuav tawm rau peb ua tsov rog tawm tsam Napoleon. Kev tawm tsam hauv Kazan xyoo 1615 kuj ceeb tias yog "qhov hluav taws kub txaus ntshai" hauv Kazan Kremlin xyoo 1815. Rau qee qhov laj thawj, tsis muaj leej twg xav tsis thoob tias cov monuments rau Minin thiab Pozharsky, uas tau liam tias coj cov tub rog mus rau Moscow thaum ntxov xyoo pua 17th, tau pib teeb tsa txhua qhov chaw tsuas yog tom qab tsov rog xyoo 1812, thiab ua ntej ntawd tsis muaj leej twg nco txog lawv rau 200. xyoo.

Ntxiv mus, qhov kev dag ntxias no yooj yim heev rau kev siv, txij li Peter kuv tau ua qhov kev hloov pauv ntawm daim ntawv qhia hnub xyoo 1700, hloov daim ntawv qhia hnub Byzantine, raws li tus account tau khaws cia "los ntawm kev tsim lub ntiaj teb." Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, nws tau sib cav tias tom qab ntawd nws yog 7208 "raws li qub style." Tab sis txawm nyob rau hauv feem ntau muaj koob muaj npe tsab cai "Nyob rau lub koob tsheej ntawm lub xyoo tshiab" nws tau hais tias kev suav ntawm lub xyoo los ntawm lub creation ntawm lub ntiaj teb no raug tshem tawm rau lawv vim muaj ib tug dav palette ntawm kev xav nyob rau hauv kev txiav txim siab qhov loj ntawm lub ntiaj teb no. lub sijhawm kawg: "rau ntau qhov sib txawv thiab suav hauv cov xyoo ntawd." Yog li, nws tsis yog qhov tseeb tias nws yog 7208, thiab tsis yog 7008. Hauv qhov no, nws yog ib qho tsim nyog yuav tsum tau kho tsuas yog ib daim ntawv, uas txuas ob lub sijhawm, tom qab ntawd tag nrho cov ntaub ntawv qub, memoirs thiab chronicles hnub tim raws li "qub style" tau hloov mus rau cov hnub tsim nyog rau cov neeg dag. Yog li ntawd, thaum peb nyeem cov ntaub ntawv ntawm Muscovy txog cov teeb meem, uas yog hnub raws li lub qub Byzantine style, txij li thaum lub Romanovs-Oldenburgs tseem tsis tau tswj Moscow, ces thaum peb rov hais dua, peb tau txais lub 1600s. Thiab thaum peb nyeem cov ntaub ntawv ntawm Romanov-Oldenburgs, peb tau txais 1800s.

Yog li ntawd, ob qho kev hloov kho ntawm lub Koom Txoos, ib qho raug liam tias nyob rau xyoo 1660, uas tau ua los ntawm Patriarch Nikon. Cov phau ntawv Orthodox qub thiab cov vaj lug kub raug txwv, cov ntawv uas twb muaj lawm raug rhuav tshem, thiab hloov pauv phau Vajlugkub tshiab Synodal tau muab, uas tau tsim. los ntawm Catholic thiab Jewish ntawv.

Ntau cov ntawv los ntawm cov neeg nyeem ua tim khawv rau tib yam. Hauv qhov thib yim txog kev tuag ntawm Tartaria, kuv tau hais ib nqe lus los ntawm lwm txoj hauv kev ntawm "Apocalypse", uas ib tug ntawm cov nyeem tau xa kuv: "thiab lub ntiaj teb yuav entangled nyob rau hauv ib tug steel web, thiab steel noog yuav ya nyob rau hauv lub ntiaj teb no. lub ntuj … tag nrho cov gullies thiab gullies yuav plows, tab sis lawv yuav tsis sau lawv cov sau." Thiab hais kom qhia seb leej twg tau hnov ib yam dab tsi zoo li ntawm lawv cov txheeb ze. Yog li ntawd, nyob rau hauv ob lub lis piam kuv tau txais ntau tshaj li plaub caug lus thiab emails nyob rau hauv uas tib neeg tau tshaj tawm hais tias lawv, ib yam nkaus thiab, tau hnov lo lus no heev los ntawm lawv pog yawg, hais tias lub ntiaj teb yuav entangled nyob rau hauv ib tug hlau web thiab hlau noog yuav ya nyob rau hauv lub. ntuj. Geography ntawm kev sib txuas lus los ntawm Moldova mus rau Far East. Qee tus kuj tseem nco qab tias yawg lossis pog txawm hais tias "cov noog hlau nrog cov nqaj hlau yuav peck rau tib neeg", ib tug neeg nco qab hais txog cov nees hlau. Ntau tus neeg kuj tau tshaj tawm tias cov kab lus no feem ntau yog los ntawm cov lus faj lem ntawm Cosmas ntawm Aetolia.

Kev tshawb fawb hauv Is Taws Nem tau muab ntau qhov kev sib txuas zoo heev nrog hais txog cov lus faj lem ntawm Cosmas ntawm Etalia, piv txwv li qhov no. Cov lus faj lem, qhov tseeb, yog qhov nthuav thiab tsim nyog kawm los ze zog, tab sis kuv tsis pom cov kab lus tshwj xeeb no raws li lub vev xaib steel thiab cov noog hlau nyob ntawd. Tom qab ntawd, lawv tau xa kuv qhov txuas mus rau ib daim ntawv PDF nrog cov ntawv uas tau liam tias Cosmas ntawm Aetolia nws tus kheej, tab sis ua ncaj ncees, kuv tsuas yog tsis muaj sijhawm los saib lawv.

Tab sis nyob rau hauv tus txheej txheem ntawm kev tshawb nrhiav, kuv pom lwm qhov txuas txuas "THOV THAWJ XEEB NTAWM LUB HOLY COSMAS ntawm ETHOLIA thiab cov laus PAISION NTAWM LUB ST. HORETS NTAWM LUB LIBERATION NTAWM LUB BALKANS THIAB CONSTANTINOPLE" Raws li cov ntawv sau txog biographical, Cosmas ntawm Etolias nyob hauv. xyoo 1714-1779. Thaum lub sij hawm thaum Cosmas yug los, cov Balkans nyob rau hauv txoj hauj lwm ntawm lub teb chaws Ottoman (Turks). Nov yog qhov lawv sau txog lub sijhawm no hauv kab lus:

“Los ntawm nws cov lus faj lem, Saint Cosmas muaj peev xwm rov qab mus rau nws cov neeg txheeb ze, uas tau poob rau hauv kev quab yuam txawv teb chaws rau ntau tshaj 300 xyoo, cia siab rau kev txhawb siab hauv lub tebchaws. Saint Cosmas qhov kev pab cuam rau yav tom ntej kev ywj pheej los ntawm Turkish txoj cai yog loj heev. Nov yog cov lus los ntawm zaj nkauj uas tau los ua lub suab nkauj ntawm cov Greeks uas tawm tsam txawv teb chaws txoj cai:

Saint George, raws li koj paub, yog tus neeg dawb huv ntawm pab tub rog. Thiab Saint Cosmas rau cov neeg koom ntawm lub teb chaws liberation zog tau los ua lub cim ntawm kev tawm tsam rau kev txhawb siab ntawm Orthodoxy thiab lub teb chaws, lawv tau txais kev tshoov siab los ntawm nws cov lus faj lem, uas ua rau muaj kev ntseeg thiab kev cia siab.

Cov neeg dawb huv, tau kawg, tsis tuaj yeem hais ncaj qha nrog nws pab yaj txog kev ywj pheej hauv tebchaws. Nws siv lo lus "xav", "xav tau". "Thaum twg 'xav tau' tuaj?" - tus neeg dawb huv feem ntau nug.

Nov yog qhov nws teb lo lus nug no:

Hauv cov lus hauv qab no, cov lus hais hauv qab no tau muab: “Cov neeg Loos yog cov neeg nyob hauv Byzantine Empire. Saint Cosmas yog tus txhawb nqa zoo ib yam ntawm kev kho dua tshiab ntawm "Romeian Empire". Nws zoo li cas? Los yog tej zaum Cosmas tsis yog tus txhawb nqa ntawm kev rov tsim "Romeian faj tim teb chaws", tab sis ntawm kev sib koom ua ke nrog Romanov faj tim teb chaws uas twb muaj lawm?

Hauv lwm lo lus, peb muaj ib qho ntxiv qhov tseeb uas qhia tau hais tias nyob rau hauv lub xyoo pua 18th lub Rome / Roman faj tim teb chaws tseem muaj, thiab nws yog Romanov faj tim teb chaws, txij li thaum nws yog nws leej twg liberated lub Balkans ntawm lub Turks nyob rau hauv 1877-1878.

Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, thaum Cosmas nyob rau xyoo pua 18th tau tawm tswv yim rau kev sib koom ua ke ntawm Romanovs rau Romanov Empire, nws tseem yog Orthodox tiag tiag, txij li thaum Romanovs tseem ua txuj ua Orthodox thiab zais lawv txoj kev sib txuas nrog cov neeg Yudais thiab tus vajtswv Yahweh / Janus. Kev hloov pauv los ntawm "kev hloov pauv", raws li kuv tau sau saum toj no, tau tshwm sim tom qab, hauv 1860s.

Qhov tseeb tias ntau tus neeg tau hnov ib kab lus los ntawm lawv cov poj koob yawm txwv, thiab nyob rau ntau qhov chaw hauv lub tebchaws, qhia tias cov ntawv no tau nthuav dav heev. Ntau tus kuj tau taw qhia tias cov no yog cov phau ntawv qub heev, uas cov yawg koob muaj nqis thiab sim tsis qhia rau leej twg lossis muab rau leej twg. Ib txhia txawm hais tias nws tsis yog phau Vaj Lug Kub Npaiv Npaum, tab sis Phau Ntawv Nkauj (Psalms, Phau Ntawv Thov Vajtswv) thiab Lub Neej Ntawm Tsoom Haiv Neeg Ntseeg. Cov ntaub ntawv keeb kwm ntawm kev txhais lus hauv phau Vajlugkub qhia txog kev txwv thiab hlawv cov ntawv luam tawm ntawm "Tshiab Vajluskub" thiab "Psalms":

Ib tug ntawm cov neeg nyeem tau tshaj tawm tias nyob rau hauv phau ntawv qub "Lub Neej ntawm Tsoom Haiv Neeg Ntseeg" muaj ib qho kev hais txog Cosmas ntawm Aetolia.

Tag nrho cov no ua ke ua pov thawj ib zaug ntxiv tias muaj lwm qhov sib txawv ntawm cov phau ntawv dawb ceev Orthodox uas tau dhau los ntawm tes mus rau tes, thiab nyob rau xyoo 1860, phau Vaj Lug Kub Npaiv Npaum tau kho dua tshiab tau tso tawm raws li kev txhais lus Synodal.

Thaum koj nyeem cov lus piav qhia ntawm "Nikon txoj kev hloov kho", tib yam tshwm sim nyob rau ntawd: "Cov phau ntawv raug kho, luam tawm thiab xa mus rau pawg ntseeg. Tus yawg koob tau thov kom hauv pawg ntseeg, thaum tau txais cov ntawv kho tshiab, lawv pib ua hauj lwm tam sim raws li phau ntawv tshiab, thiab cov qub yuav tsum muab tso tseg thiab muab zais. Cov kab ke kho tau raug qhia nrog rau cov phau ntawv. " Ntawd yog, nyob rau xyoo pua 17th Nikon tau liam tias coj kev txiav txim ob qho tib si hauv kev cai dab qhuas thiab hauv "cov vaj lug kub", tab sis 200 xyoo dhau los thiab qhov kev txiav txim no yuav tsum tau rov qab los dua, tso tawm phau Vajlugkub kho dua tshiab, thaum txwv thiab rhuav tshem yav dhau los. cov ntawv luam? Kuv ntseeg tias qhov kev hloov pauv tiag tiag tau tshwm sim los ntawm qhov kawg ntawm lub xyoo pua 19th, thiab tsis yog nyob rau xyoo pua 17th, txij li cov phau ntawv txwv tsis pub muaj sia nyob mus rau peb lub sijhawm nyob rau ntau tus lej.

Nyob rau tib lub sijhawm, lawv tab tom sim ua kom peb paub tseeb tias Nikon qhov kev hloov kho tsuas yog coj kev txiav txim, tshem tawm qhov tsis sib xws ntawm Moscow thiab Greek Churches. Zoo, peb hla peb tus kheej nrog ob ntiv tes, thiab tam sim no peb xav tau peb. Yam tsawg kawg ntawm chav kawm keeb kwm ntawm tsev kawm ntawv, cov neeg feem coob nco txog qhov no xwb. Qhov ntawd yog, lawv tab tom sim ntxias peb tias nws yog qhov teeb meem tseem ceeb uas tib neeg vim qhov no tau npaj tuag, tab sis tsis lees txais cov kev hloov pauv?

Cia peb pom dab tsi sab nraud, Lub Koom Txoos Kav Tos Liv Laus Lavxias, tshaj tawm txog Nikon txoj kev hloov kho:

“Cov kev hloov pauv hauv phau ntawv tau ua raws li lwm lub koom txoos kev tsim kho tshiab. Qhov tseem ceeb tshaj plaws ntawm cov no yog cov hauv qab no:

- es tsis txhob ntawm ob tug ntiv tes kos npe rau ntawm tus ntoo khaub lig, uas tau saws nyob rau hauv Russia los ntawm lub Byzantine Orthodox lub tsev teev ntuj ua ke nrog cov ntseeg Vajtswv thiab uas yog ib feem ntawm lub Holy Apostolic kev lig kev cai, peb-ntiv tes kos npe rau yog qhia;

- nyob rau hauv cov phau ntawv qub, raws li tus ntsuj plig ntawm cov lus Slavic, lub npe ntawm tus Cawm Seej "Yexus" yeej ib txwm sau thiab hais; nyob rau hauv cov ntawv tshiab lub npe no tau hloov mus rau Greekized "Yexus";

- nyob rau hauv cov phau ntawv qub nws yog tsim nyob rau lub sij hawm ua kev cai raus dej, kab tshoob thiab fij rau lub tuam tsev mus taug kev nyob rau hauv lub hnub raws li ib tug kos npe rau hais tias. tias peb ua raws li Tswv Yexus lub hnub … Cov phau ntawv tshiab tau qhia txog kev ua haujlwm tiv thaiv lub hnub;

- nyob rau hauv cov phau ntawv qub nyob rau hauv Creed (8th lub sij hawm) nws nyeem: "Thiab nyob rau hauv tus ntsuj plig ntawm tus Vaj Ntsuj Plig Dawb Huv, muaj tseeb thiab txoj sia-muab"; tom qab kho, lo lus "Istinnago" raug tshem tawm;

- es tsis txhob augmented, uas yog, ob npaug Alleluia, uas lub Koom Txoos Lavxias teb sab tau tsim txij thaum ub, ib daim duab peb sab (uas yog, triple) Alleluia tau qhia;

- Divine Liturgy nyob rau hauv Ancient Russia tau ua nyob rau xya prosphora; tus tshiab "cov thawj coj" qhia tsib prosphora, uas yog, ob prosphora raug tshem tawm."

Tam sim no qhov no nthuav ntau dua. Ua ntej, ntawm no peb pom lwm qhov qhia tias Orthodox ua ntej kev hloov kho yog cov neeg pe hawm hnub ci. Qhov thib ob, qhov kev hloov ntawm kev taw qhia tseem ceeb dua li tus naj npawb ntawm cov ntiv tes. Muaj ob hom ntawm lub ntsiab swastika, txoj cai, raws li lub hnub, thiab sab laug, tawm tsam lub hnub, thaum qhov txawv ntawm lawv yog tsis tshua muaj piav qhia meej.

41 SV - sab laug thiab sab xis swastikas 1
41 SV - sab laug thiab sab xis swastikas 1

Koj tuaj yeem pom cov lus hais tias "txoj cai" swastika yog qhov zoo, thiab "sab laug" yog qhov phem. Qhov no yog vim qhov tseeb tias nws yog sab laug swastika uas tau siv los ua ib lub cim hauv Nazi lub teb chaws Yelemees. Rau tib lub laj thawj, tam sim no lawv tab tom sim ua txhaum cai ntawm swastika.

42 SV - German cim
42 SV - German cim

Qhov tseeb, txhua lub cim tsis zoo lossis phem. Nws tag nrho yog nyob ntawm lub ntsiab lus ntawm qhov no lossis pawg neeg ntawm lub cim no. Tus cwj pwm tsis zoo ntawm swastika, uas yog tshwj xeeb hauv thaj chaw ntawm lub qub USSR, yog txuam nrog tus cwj pwm tsis zoo rau Nazism thiab lawv cov kev ua phem, uas yog subconsciously kis mus rau lub cim lawv siv. Tib lub sijhawm, ntawm lwm haiv neeg, cov cim no muaj lub ntsiab lus sib txawv kiag li. Ua ntej, feem ntau cov kws tshawb fawb pom zoo tias lub cim no yog qhov qub heev thiab pom thoob plaws ntiaj teb. (cov ntaub ntawv loj tshaj plaws ntawm cov pov thawj keeb kwm: lub album Lub ntsiab hnub ci cim - ed.) Tsis tas li ntawd, feem ntau pom zoo tias qhov no yog lub hnub ci lub cim, uas yog, denoting lub hnub thiab nws nruam txav nyob ib ncig ntawm lub ntiaj teb.

Hais txog sab laug thiab txoj cai ntawm swastika, muaj cov kev xav hauv qab no:

"Cov ntaub ntawv ncaj qha thiab thim rov qab ntawm swastika - txiv neej thiab poj niam, hnub ci thiab lub hli pib, clockwise thiab counterclockwise txav, thiab kuj, pom tseeb, ob hemispheres, saum ntuj ceeb tsheej thiab chthonic quab yuam, nce caij nplooj ntoos hlav thiab caij nplooj zeeg lub hnub";

"Yog hais tias Kolovrat tig clockwise (sab xis-sab swastika), ces qhov no txhais tau hais tias tseem ceeb zog, yog hais tias tawm tsam (sab laug-sab), ces qhov no qhia hais tias ib tug thov rau Navi, lub ntiaj teb no ntawm cov poj koob yawm txwv thiab Vajtswv (uas yog, kev tuag). Tsis tas li ntawd, nyob rau hauv Indian kev ntseeg, sab laug thiab sab xis swastikas qhia txog poj niam thiab txiv neej lub zog, zoo li yin thiab yang: sab xis yog txiv neej lub zog, sab laug - feem, poj niam. Nws yog qhov muaj peev xwm xav tias nyob hauv lub ntiaj teb thaum ub, cov Slavs kuj muaj xws li kev faib tawm."

Ntawm Orthodox lub tsev teev ntuj thiab cov cim, ob sab laug thiab sab xis swastikas muaj nyob rau hauv cov lej loj, uas, dua, ib zaug ntxiv qhia tias Orthodoxy yog ib qho kev ntseeg ntawm cov neeg pe hawm hnub. Thiab los ntawm qhov kev xav ntawm lub hnub pe hawm, nws yog txoj cai swastika thiab lub zog "nrog ntsev" uas yuav cim lub hnub thiab kev txav mus rau yav tom ntej, tab sis sab laug swastika txhais tau tias txav mus rau yav dhau los, raws li tau hais hauv cov lus kawg., ib qho kev thov rau lub ntiaj teb ntawm Navi, qhov twg cov ntsuj plig ntawm cov neeg tuag nyob tab sis tseem tsis tau rov incarnated poj koob yawm txwv. Tias yog vim li cas sab laug swastika feem ntau pom nyob rau tombstones, monuments, raws li zoo raws li nyob rau hauv lub tsim ntawm cathedrals los yog ib feem ntawm lawv, uas tau mob siab rau lub ntiaj teb no ntawm Navi, uas yog, rau kev sib txuas lus nrog cov poj koob yawm txwv tuag.

Yog li ntawd, qhov kev hloov pauv ntawm kev txav mus rau qhov sib txawv ntawm lub hnub tsis tau txais los ntawm Lub Koom Txoos Qub Ntseeg thiab raug txiav txim siab los ntawm nws raws li kev sim hloov lub hnub ci kev ntseeg nrog lub lunar.

Tab sis qhov kev hloov ntawm kev taw qhia tsuas yog ib qho laj thawj xwb, txawm hais tias tseem ceeb dua li tus ntiv tes los ua kev cai raus dej. Nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, nyob rau hauv lub guise ntawm "reform" thiab "kho qhov yuam kev," lub Orthodox worldview yog hloov los ntawm cov ntseeg kev ntseeg rau qhev. Qhov ntawd yog, nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, tib yam uas tshwm sim nyob rau hauv lub USSR thaum lub sij hawm Gorbachev lub "perestroika", uas thaum kawg coj mus rau ib tug tiav kev hloov ntawm lub tswv yim thiab lub cev qhuav dej ntawm lub USSR.

Dmitry Mylnikov

Tus sau tsab xov xwm ntawm Kramol:

"Yuav ua li cas Tartary Perished". Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Part 5 Part 6 Part 7 Part 8

"Lub Ntiaj Teb Zoo Kawg Peb Poob." Part 1 Part 2

Pom zoo: